​In their debut appearance at the USACFC championships in 2004, Cornell was the Men’s Three-Weapon Team Champions - a feat they repeated in 2018 and 2024. Each weapon squad has also earned championship titles: Foil (2006, 2009, 2014); Saber (2012, 2025); Epee (2004, 2017, 2024). In 2024, the Epee squad earned gold and both the Foil and Saber squads earned silver, leading them to first place in Men's Combined in a field of over 42 teams from across the country, In individual competition, Lucas Lutar won gold in Foil; Langston Johnson won silver in Saber; and Nihal Bankulla won bronze in Epee. In 2025 Sabre won gold and the team placed third in the Men's Combined; Cole Leonard earned bronze in Sabre. 

​

Men's Fencing also medals frequently at MACFA, where they compete against NCAA teams.; the Foil squad has earned league titles four times and Sabre and Epee once. In 2022 the Epee squad placed second, and Max Dolmetsch and Lucas Luthar won bronze in individual Epee and Foil. In 2024, Langston Johnson won silver in Sabre. In 2025, the team placed third; the Sabre squad placed third; and Michael Wu earned silver in Foil and Langston Johnson earned bronze in Sabre.